Woman gets pregnant while in a vegetative state
Nathan Sutherland, a nurse at the Phoenix-based Hacienda HealthCare long-term care facility, is accused of sexually assaulting the woman. A court filing by the family of a woman who gave birth while in a long-term vegetative condition in an Arizona nursing facility states that according to doctors who examined her, the woman had likely been pregnant before. The notice of claim also cites the findings of Dr. Nathan Sutherland , 37, a nurse at the Phoenix-based Hacienda HealthCare long-term care facility, was arrested earlier this year, and has pleaded not guilty to one count of sexual assault and one count of vulnerable adult abuse. Click here to get breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases in the True Crime Newsletter.SEE VIDEO BY TOPIC: Man pregnant a woman in vegetative state,Woman gets pregnant while in vegetative state
- How Could a Woman in a Vegetative State Get Pregnant and Give Birth? An Ob-Gyn Explains
- Woman in Vegetative State Who Gave Birth in Facility Had Likely Been Pregnant Multiple Times: Docs
- Comatose woman gets pregnant and no one notices? How does that happen?
- Police Investigate Sexual Assault Allegations After Woman in Vegetative State Gives Birth
- Woman in 14-Year Coma Gives Birth in Arizona
- Woman who gave birth in a vegetative state may not have shown signs of pregnancy
How Could a Woman in a Vegetative State Get Pregnant and Give Birth? An Ob-Gyn Explains
On December 29, a woman who had been in a vegetative state for over two decades gave birth in an Arizona nursing facility, prompting authorities to investigate what looks like a case of sexual assault. Days later, the CEO of the corporation that runs the nursing home resigned. Though it was previously reported that the woman had been a patient at Hacienda HealthCare for about 14 years, new records obtained by People found that she had been at the facility since she was between the ages of 2 and 3.
The records also indicated that she has quadriplegia and a seizure disorder, along with recurrent pneumonia. A nurse was apparently on hand to deliver the baby, but the alleged months-long oversight does suggest negligence. None whatsoever. Not even able to communicate the fact that she was pregnant. Over a week after she gave birth, the woman was identified as a member of the San Carlos Apache Tribe in Arizona. According to tribe officials, she is 29 years old. This post has been updated throughout.
Already a subscriber? Log in or link your magazine subscription. Account Profile. Sign Out. A patient in a Phoenix nursing facility gave birth last week, despite being in a vegetative state for decades.
Tags: power crime sexual abuse sexual assault pregnancy More. Most Viewed Stories. Best of The Cut. More Stories.
Woman in Vegetative State Who Gave Birth in Facility Had Likely Been Pregnant Multiple Times: Docs
Medical experts said it was possible that a woman in a vegetative state who gave birth to a child in a care home in Arizona last year would display no outward signs that she was pregnant. A doctor examined the woman nearly nine months before she gave birth but did not find that she was pregnant and the experts said it was plausible that the workers who cared for her every day would not have noticed either. Police are looking for her rapist and say it appears none of the staff members at a Phoenix long-term care facility knew about the pregnancy until the baby was born December 29, a notion that has drawn scepticism. But the year-old woman, who is described in a medical report as having tubes to feed her and help her breathe, may not have had a swollen belly, according to a doctor of foetal medicine. While factors remain unknown, such as how far along she was, someone who is fed the same amount from a tube every day might not show any dramatic changes that would be noticed, especially by staffers who don't work with pregnant patients, said C Kevin Huls, a clinical assistant professor and maternal-foetal medicine fellowship director at the University of Arizona.
A horrifying story has been in headlines this week: A year-old woman in a vegetative state at the Hacienda HealthCare facility in Phoenix gave birth to a baby boy on December The woman had been in this state for 14 years after nearly drowning. She is considered a sexual assault victim, and police are collecting DNA samples from male workers at the facility in an attempt to identify who assaulted her. While the hunt for her assailant is in progress, the case has raised the question: How could a woman who for 14 years has presumably displayed no awareness and little brain functioning conceive a child and give birth? First, it helps to know what a vegetative state is.
Comatose woman gets pregnant and no one notices? How does that happen?
Hacienda Healthcare employees also missed other signs of pregnancy, including swelling in her extremities, something that was purportedly so pronounced that it was noted by the woman's family members in December, shortly before she gave birth, according to the claim. The staff first noticed the pregnancy on Dec. A panicked call , previously released, captured the moments immediately following the baby's birth. Asked if the mother is "doing OK," the caller replies, "We're not sure, we had no idea this patient was pregnant. The woman and her child were then taken to the Maricopa County Medical Center for treatment, where it was noted, according to the claim, that the patient had likely been "violated repeatedly," both vaginally and anally. The claim also states that doctors noted this was likely a "repeat parous event," indicating the woman may have been pregnant prior to carrying her son to full term. Complicating matters, according to the claim, the woman's family had asked for only female staff members to care for her, a request that was allegedly ignored, as evidenced by the pregnancy. He is charged with sexual assault and abusing a vulnerable adult.
Police Investigate Sexual Assault Allegations After Woman in Vegetative State Gives Birth
The disturbing case of an Arizona woman who gave birth despite being in a vegetative state for more than a decade is not the first of its kind, experts told NBC News. The woman, 29, delivered in December while receiving long-term care at Hacienda HealthCare in Phoenix after a near-drowning incident. Authorities do not know who impregnated her and have opened a sexual assault investigation in search of her rapist. The case echoes one from , when a comatose year-old woman was raped by a nurse's aide at her nursing home near Rochester, New York. Staff discovered she was pregnant early on, a key difference between her and the Arizona woman.
Severe maternal neurologic injury during pregnancy has the potential for fetal demise without advanced critical care support to the mother. Brain death is the unequivocal and irreversible loss of total brain function, whereas patients in a vegetative state, by contrast, have preserved brain stem function but lack cerebral function. They can appear to be awake, have sleep-wake cycles, be capable of swallowing, and have normal respiratory control, but there are no purposeful interactions. These conditions have different maternal prognoses, but both have resulted in near-normal neonatal outcomes with long latencies from maternal injury to delivery in previously published cases.
Woman in 14-Year Coma Gives Birth in Arizona
Hacienda HealthCare in Phoenix has said that they will continue to work with law enforcement. Update: Nathan Sutherland, a year-old nurse at the Hacienda HealthCare facility has been arrested and charged with one count of sexual assault and one count of vulnerable adult abuse, according to the Associated Press. The CEO of a Phoenix, Arizona, health facility has resigned amid a police investigation into the rape and subsequent pregnancy of a female patient who has been a vegetative state for more than a decade.
Already a member? Sign in. Nursing care , Nursing perceptions of care , Persistent vegetative state , Pregnancy. Purpose: To explore the perceptions of labor and delivery nurses caring for women in persistent vegetative states with viable pregnancies. Study Design and Method: For this qualitative research study, participants included a purposive sample of 13 RNs who provided bedside care to pregnant women in persistent vegetative states.
Woman who gave birth in a vegetative state may not have shown signs of pregnancy
Police in Arizona have made an arrest in connection with a woman who gave birth while in a vegetative state. Authorities said he was responsible for caring for the woman at the time of the alleged abuse that appears to have resulted in the pregnancy, a spokeswoman for the Phoenix Police Department announced in a press conference Wednesday. Sutherland had been a licensed practical nurse at Hacienda Healthcare in Phoenix since , police said. He was identified as a person who had access to the victim in the case, and investigators obtained a DNA sample from him yesterday using a court order, police said. A statement released through the family's attorney, John Micheaels, on Wednesday said they were aware of the arrest but declined to comment further, asking for privacy. On Tuesday, Micheaels released a statement saying the family "would like to make clear that their daughter is not in a coma. Their daughter responds to sound and is able to make facial gestures. The important thing is that she is a beloved daughter, albeit with significant intellectual disabilities.
Workers at the facility were shocked when the non-verbal patient, who has been severely disabled and in an incapacitated state from the age of three, went into labour and gave birth to a baby boy last December. According to the legal papers, obtained by Sun Online, doctors who examined her following the birth concluded that the baby "was obviously a result of a non-consensual sexual assault". They also discovered a series of old injuries that suggesting a history of sexual assault or trauma "prior to this delivery". Shockingly, medical records also showed that this may not have been the first time the victim had been pregnant, stating an examination suggested "repeat coitus has occurred and likely this is a repeat parous event".
On December 29, a woman who had been in a vegetative state for over two decades gave birth in an Arizona nursing facility, prompting authorities to investigate what looks like a case of sexual assault. Days later, the CEO of the corporation that runs the nursing home resigned. Though it was previously reported that the woman had been a patient at Hacienda HealthCare for about 14 years, new records obtained by People found that she had been at the facility since she was between the ages of 2 and 3. The records also indicated that she has quadriplegia and a seizure disorder, along with recurrent pneumonia.
CNN A year-old nurse has been arrested on suspicion of impregnating a woman in a vegetative state who unexpectedly gave birth last month at a Phoenix health care facility, police said Wednesday. Chat with us in Facebook Messenger. Find out what's happening in the world as it unfolds.